TEST 1: variable number of Access Conditions. (5 triples/AC) Shi3ld-LDP -SPARQLless AC count No ACs 5 10 20 50 100 run1 2.48 5.56 6.98 7.9 12.50 20.12 run2 2.34 5.96 7.06 7.28 13.18 18.34 run3 2.78 5.18 6.94 7.66 13.42 20.34 run4 2.48 5.46 6.92 7.78 12.48 18.6 run5 2.48 5.54 6.68 7.56 13.22 18.98 Avg 2.51 5.54 6.92 7.64 12.96 19.28 stddev 0.161616831 0.279642629 0.142407865 0.236389509 0.438634244 0.903482153 Faster than Internal SPARQL (%) 23.14 17.43 27.85 24.12 31.13 Faster than Internal SPARQL (Average) 24.73 Shi3ld-LDP - Internal SPARQL endpoint AC count No ACs 5 10 20 50 100 run1 2.3 7.3 8.36 10.42 17.68 27.3 run2 2.26 7.16 8.66 10.52 16.76 27.44 run3 2.26 7.1 8.38 10.62 16.62 29.18 run4 2.3 7.34 8.10 10.82 17.5 27.18 run5 2.18 7.14 8.38 10.54 16.84 28.84 Avg 2.26 7.21 8.38 10.58 17.08 27.99 stddev 0.048989795 0.105451411 0.198191826 0.149933319 0.47644517 0.945156072 Shi3ld-GSP (empty fuseki) AC count No ACs 5 10 20 50 100 run1 3.1 22.54 33.30 54.3 114.18 211.64 run2 3.14 22.54 34.18 53.44 113.24 211.08 run3 3.12 23.62 38.84 53.22 111.74 211.94 run4 3.1 23.98 32.76 51.6 112.82 212.94 run5 3.4 22.9 35.96 50.5 112.9 212.02 Avg 3.17 23.12 35.01 52.61 112.98 211.92 stddev 0.128530152 0.653972476 2.462056051 1.532096603 0.877086085 0.677259182 "Shi3ld-GSP (~10M triples, 17k graphs - timbl/data-4.nq.gz 9405528)" AC count No ACs 5 10 20 50 100 run1 3.24 32.1 43.40 62.3 125.02 215.18 run2 3.32 32.02 44.14 61.8 117.2 219.62 run3 3.16 31.4 43.86 61.4 115 215.92 run4 3.36 32.02 44.62 62.76 114.82 216 run5 3.22 30.58 44.38 58.64 114.46 215.06 Avg 3.26 31.62 44.08 61.38 117.30 216.36 stddev 0.08 0.648135788 0.473286383 1.615178009 4.447313796 1.873040309 Slower than empty (%) 26.90 20.58 14.28 3.69 2.05 Slower than empty (Average) 13.50 TEST 2: variable number of triples. 1 AC only Shi3ld-GSP (empty fuseki) triple/AC No ACs 1 AC (5 triples) 1 AC (10 triples) 1 AC (20 triples) 1 AC (20 triples + FILTER) run1 3.1 14.72 14.50 13.7 13.44 run2 3.14 14.64 14.44 13.78 14.06 run3 3.12 15.1 14.44 14.02 14.78 run4 3.1 14.28 15.92 14.64 13.88 run5 3.4 14.22 13.88 14.9 14.26 Avg 3.17 14.59 14.64 14.21 14.08 stddev 0.128530152 0.357938542 0.760841639 0.534340715 0.493031439 Shi3ld-LDP - Internal SPARQL endpoint triple/AC No ACs 1 AC (5 triples) 1 AC (10 triples) 1 AC (20 triples) 1 AC (20 triples + FILTER) run1 2.3 5.4 5.86 6.18 6.50 run2 2.26 5.08 5.38 5.46 5.78 run3 2.26 5.36 5.32 5.66 5.88 run4 2.3 5.28 5.36 6.48 6.2 run5 2.18 5.28 5.70 6.5 5.5 Avg 2.26 5.28 5.52 6.06 5.97 stddev 0.048989795 0.12328828 0.24141251 0.475478706 0.386936687 Shi3ld-LDP -SPARQLless triple/AC No ACs 1 AC (5 triples) 1 AC (10 triples) 1 AC (20 triples) run1 2.48 4.44 4.20 4.92 run2 2.34 4.98 4.24 5.1 run3 2.78 4.46 5.32 5.06 run4 2.48 4.96 4.86 5.2 run5 2.48 4.16 4.86 5.12 Avg 2.51 4.60 4.70 5.08 stddev 0.161616831 0.358050276 0.473582094 0.102956301 "TEST 3: response time for different HTTP operations (1 AC, 5 triples)" Shi3ld-GSP (empty fuseki) w/access control GET POST PUT DELETE run1 14.72 14.76 15.56 13.28 run2 14.64 14.84 14.64 13.72 run3 15.1 14.86 14.9 13.6 run4 14.28 14.5 15.3 13.38 run5 14.22 14.76 14.78 13.62 Avg 14.59 14.74 15.04 13.52 stddev 0.357938542 0.143805424 0.382465685 0.182756669 Shi3ld-GSP (empty fuseki) - unprotected GET POST PUT DELETE run1 3.1 3.26 3.12 2.52 run2 3.14 3.22 3.48 2.28 run3 3.12 3.30 3.44 2.3 run4 3.1 3.22 3.28 2.52 run5 3.4 3.22 3.32 2.22 Avg 3.17 3.24 3.33 2.37 stddev 0.128530152 0.035777088 0.142548237 0.141844986 Shi3ld-LDP - Internal SPARQL endpoint w/access control GET POST PUT DELETE run1 5.4 5.34 5.40 5.08 run2 5.08 5.46 5.32 5.2 run3 5.36 5.36 5.08 4.56 run4 5.28 5.24 5.52 5.02 run5 5.28 5.22 5.62 4.84 Avg 5.28 5.32 5.39 4.94 stddev 0.12328828 0.097365292 0.206688171 0.248997992 Shi3ld-LDP - Internal SPARQL endpoint - unprotected GET POST PUT DELETE run1 2.06 2.16 2.20 2.14 run2 2.06 2.12 2.12 2.06 run3 2.1 2.22 2.10 2.2 run4 2.18 2.18 2.02 2.06 run5 2.06 2.04 2.02 2.16 Avg 2.09 2.14 2.09 2.12 stddev 0.052153619 0.068410526 0.075630682 0.062289646 Shi3ld-LDP -SPARQLless w/access control GET POST PUT DELETE run1 4.44 4.64 4.34 4.9 run2 4.98 4.38 4.36 4.14 run3 4.46 4.32 4.50 4.14 run4 4.96 4.4 4.56 4.58 run5 4.16 4.64 4.36 3.92 Avg 4.60 4.48 4.42 4.34 stddev 0.358050276 0.152577849 0.099398189 0.3960808 Shi3ld-LDP -SPARQLless - unprotected GET POST PUT DELETE run1 2.24 2.04 2.10 2.08 run2 2.34 2.1 2.06 2.18 run3 2.18 2.1 2.30 2.16 run4 2.12 2.12 2.06 2.16 run5 2.14 2.14 2.06 2.06 Avg 2.20 2.10 2.12 2.13 stddev 0.088769364 0.037416574 0.104307238 0.054037024 Deltas GSP 11.42 11.50 11.71 11.15 LDP1 3.19 3.18 3.30 2.82 LDP2 2.40 2.38 2.31 2.21 stddev GSP 0.486468694 0.179582512 0.525013922 0.324601655 stddev LDP1 0.175441899 0.165775817 0.282318853 0.311287638 stddev LDP2 0.44681964 0.189994423 0.203705428 0.450117824